Haunted Places in New Haven, Indiana



  • 0

    Mason Long House

    Fort Wayne, Indiana

    5.9 miles from New Haven, IN

    Mason Long was born in 1842 and was orphaned by age 10. He got a job and later fought in the Civil War. After that he became a businessman and ended up a successful stockbroker. He died here of a stroke in 1902. The private home is said to be ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Pfeiffer House

    Fort Wayne, Indiana

    6.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Pfeiffer House restaurant was built in 1905 as the Pfeiffer family home, and is said to be haunted by Fred Pfeiffer, who grew up in the house. Fred moved into an assisted-living center in 1989 and passed away in 1994, only to return to his beloved home. According to ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Old Whitley Jail

    Columbia City, Indiana

    25.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    Old Whitley Jail, constructed in 1875, is said to be haunted by Charles Butler, a bully and alcoholic who shot his wife in the back in 1883. He was jailed here but escaped with four other prisoners when Sheriff Frank Allwein was out. But Butler was caught shortly thereafter when ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Strand Theatre

    Kendallville, Indiana

    28.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Strand movie theater is haunted by a previous owner, whose apparition has been seen by many people in different locations throughout the building. The ghost also has been known to watch patrons through the projection room window, but ducks when anyone looks at him.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Restoration Lutheran Church

    Kendallville, Indiana

    28.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    At Restoration Lutheran Church, witnesses say, you may hear ghostly footsteps on the stairs, see apparitions of faces in mirrors, and hear strange scratching sounds. You might detect hot and cold spots and see tall, dark figures that may even toss chairs at you.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Ceylon Covered Bridge

    Geneva, Indiana

    31.7 miles from New Haven, IN

    Local legend has it that many years ago a group of teens performed a séance here, during which a body fell to the floor, leaving a big blood stain near the pentagram they drew. The experience is rumored to have opened a portal from which strange things come.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Miami Erie Antique-Collectible Mall

    Delphos, Ohio

    38.6 miles from New Haven, IN

    Formerly the Pennsylvania Railroad Hotel, this antiques mall is rumoured to be haunted by a phantom traveller who passed away in an upstairs room. Customers to the store have sworn they've heard footsteps coming from the second level, but upon investigation, there is no one around. There are also ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Barbee Hotel

    Warsaw, Indiana

    39.4 miles from New Haven, IN

    This historic hotel was frequented by Al Capone, who would stay in Room 301 and clear out all the rest of the guests so he could be alone. Cleaning staff have smelled cigar smoke coming from his room and have seen an ghostly man sitting in a booth in the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Old Kosciusko County Jail and Museum

    Warsaw, Indiana

    45.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Old Kosciusko County Jail was in operation from 1870 to 1982. In 1982 the new Justice Building was completed and took over the housing of the inmates. The Old Jail subsequently became the home of the Kosciusko Historical Society now shares the county Genealogy Library. Employees, volunteers and visitors ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Kaup Pharmacy - Homestead Restaurant

    Portland, Ohio

    47.1 miles from New Haven, IN

    Once known as Homestead Food and Spirits, the building that houses the Kaup Pharmacy is said to have a ghostly resident. A lady's apparition has been spotted, and the door to the women's restroom has been known to open and close on its own.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Finch Cemetery

    Portland, Indiana

    49.9 miles from New Haven, IN

    The late-1800s Finch Cemetery at the Jay County Conservation Club is said to hold the grave of a boy named Cinderella. Rumor has it that the gravestones here shift, or disappear. If you count the gravestones on the way to Cinderella's grave, you will count 13. But on the way ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Gray Hotel

    Redkey, Indiana

    50.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    This 1912 former hotel now houses the offices of a paranormal investigative team, who claim that the building is one of the most haunted in the entire state. With its troubling past of murder, manslaughter and illegal activity, it isn't that hard to believe either. At least two, possibly ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Dixie Lee Restaurant

    Cridersville, Ohio

    54.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    Hector is the name the staff members have given to the ghost who haunts Dixie Lee Restaurant. His apparition has been spotted inside the restaurant, and he isn't rumored to be the quiet type--Hector has been known to make a lot of noise.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Okie Pinokie

    Peru, Indiana

    55 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Okie Pinokie Woods, according to local legend, are full of disembodied spirits. One of the many legends about the place centers on Joey Peoria, a young man who disappeared while camping in 1976. Brutally murdered men began showing up in the area, and folks say it was Joey who ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Fulton County Historical Museum

    Wauseon, Ohio

    55.9 miles from New Haven, IN

    This historical society and museum was formerly a schoolhouse and a hospital, and staff believe the thirteenth oldest historic museum in the state is haunted. Built in the mid-nineteenth century, staff say the county museum has its fair share of history; and ghost stories. The first apparition seen is a ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Tillett Cemetery - Hookman's Cemetery

    Peru, Indiana

    57.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    Tillett Cemetery is also known as Hookman's Cemetery because of a local tale of a ghostly man with a hook for a hand who prowls the nearby roads looking for victims. Thick, eerie fogs and cold spots are known to materialize in the area as well.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Elkheart Civic Theatre

    Bristol, Indiana

    61.2 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Elkhart Civic Theatre (aka Bristol Opera House), housed in an 1897 building, is said to be haunted by ghosts who send books and papers flying off shelves, levitate small objects, run sewing machines and project moving shafts of light. Shadows and an apparition of a floating dark-haired woman have ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Winchester Mansion

    Elkhart, Indiana

    65.2 miles from New Haven, IN

    The 1905 Winchester Mansion is home to the ghost of former resident Nellie Knickerbocker, some say. Folks working at the businesses housed in the mansion have noted the attic light coming on by itself, objects falling off shelves, and strange sounds. Reports tell us that when Nellie Knickerbocker was alive, ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Lerner Theatre

    Elkhart, Indiana

    65.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    Lerner Theatre is believed to be haunted by the ghost of a tech director who had a heart attack and died on the job. Witnesses say lights flicker and strange sounds come from the attic, and a ghostly figure, some say, can be seen in the second-floor box seats when ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Ruthmere Mansion

    Elkhart, Indiana

    65.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    Ruthmere Mansion is rumored to be haunted; witnesses say the ghosts set off alarms and sirens inside the mansion especially on Halloween. Some report the sound of phantom gunshots here as well. It should be noted that employees at the house museum say they have never experienced any hauntings here.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Victorian Villa Bed and Breakfast

    Union City, Michigan

    69.4 miles from New Haven, IN

    This historic bed and breakfast was built in the 1870's as a retirement residence for a notable family. Since its conversion in the 1980's to a bed and breakfast, guests and staff have reported sighting the apparition of a stern lady in an old-fashioned presence, whose presence is often accompanied ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    St. Clair Memorial Hall

    Greenville, Ohio

    70.1 miles from New Haven, IN

    St. Clair Memorial Hall was built in 1910 and has an old man's spirit lingering inside, folks say. The hall, where plays and musicals are performed, is haunted by a man who fell to his death while changing a light bulb.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Bonnyconnellan Castle

    Sidney, Ohio

    70.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    The apparition of a regal man in a blue military uniform has been seen on the landing, examining a display. (Submitted by Callum Swift)


    Read more »
  • 0

    2220 N Armstrong St

    Kokomo, Indiana

    70.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    2220 N. Armstrong Kokomo Indiana is now an empty lot. There is no longer a home on the property. It was burned by a serial arsonist. He caused more than 22 structural fires in Kokomo. My childhood home was his last. The arsonist lived ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Bear's Mill

    Greenville, Ohio

    71.1 miles from New Haven, IN

    Bear’s Mill, an operating water-powered mill and historic landmark, was built in 1849 by Gabriel Baer. It is said to be haunted by a former owner, whose ghost can be heard walking on the creaking floorboards upstairs when no one is there.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Trestle Bridge

    Adrian, Michigan

    72.5 miles from New Haven, IN

    Trestle Bridge has a legend with a ghost. So the story goes, a farmhouse once stood nearby, and it burned down late one night. The owner went to the barn to try to save the horses, and the wife and son went to the train tracks under Trestle Bridge to ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hacienda Restaurant

    Mishawaka, Indiana

    73.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    Once a private mansion, Hacienda Mexican Restaurant is rumored to be haunted by apparitions of those who used to live here. Some stories say one apparition belongs to a maid with whom the mansion's owner had an affair. When the maid became pregnant, he shunned her, so she hanged herself ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Columbian House Hotel

    Waterville, Ohio

    73.6 miles from New Haven, IN

    Back in 1828, when this historic hotel was constructed, it was merely a trading post and tavern with limited overnight accommodation. At various times throughout the century, the building also served as a prison and a town ballroom. The strange history of the building began back in the 1840's, after ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Mount Hope Cemetery

    Logansport, Indiana

    73.7 miles from New Haven, IN

    Phantom sounds of horses and whistles that echo your own have been reported in this cemetery that dates back to the 1800s. Also, some reports say there are mausoleums here with spooky inscriptions like "Knock three times and they shall come."


    Read more »
  • 0

    Sam B's Restaurant

    Bowling Green, Ohio

    73.9 miles from New Haven, IN

    The third floor of this restaurant was once a theatre and was the site of a murder years ago. The theatre is now closed to the public, but employees have reported many strange occurrences. They also believe the kitchen is haunted. At least two employees have died in the ...


    Read more »

  • Haunted Indiana 3
    Mark Marimen

    Ghosts of Madison, Indiana
    Virginia Dyer Jorgensen
  • 0

    Bowling Green State University

    Bowling Green, Ohio

    75 miles from New Haven, IN

    Bowling Green State University's ghosts include Alice, a deceased actress who haunts Brown and Saint Theaters and must have a formal invitation to every theater performance, and Amanda, who haunts the Chi Omega Sorority House. Amanda was killed accidentally in an initiation, and is a poltergeist. At one time, the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wood County Historical Center

    Bowling Green, Ohio

    75.2 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Wood County Historical Center and Museum building used to house the Wood County Home/Infirmary, which opened in 1869 and operated until 1971. The museum opened in 1975. It is believed to be haunted by former patients of the infirmary. Reports have been made of an apparition of a lady ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    State Theatre

    Anderson, Indiana

    75.4 miles from New Haven, IN

    The State Theatre was opened in 1930 with eco friendly geo thermal heat and air system way before it's time and an acoustically engineered dome for the best sound for the first talkies. People have felt and seen various apparitions and vague whisperings in several places in the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Fort Piqua Hotel

    Piqua, Ohio

    75.5 miles from New Haven, IN

    Built in 1891, the historic Fort Piqua Hotel was once a library, and then stood empty for years. Now it is said to be haunted by a handyman who died in 1910 after falling into a barrel of cleaning acid. His ghost is seen working on things or shoveling coal ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Fallen Timbers Battlefield

    Maumee, Ohio

    75.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    The 1794 Battle of Fallen Timbers was the last battle of the Northwest Indian War. On the anniversary of the battle, August 20, ghostly soldiers are said to re-enact the battle.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Holiday Inn City Center

    South Bend, Indiana

    76.6 miles from New Haven, IN

    Pilots and flight attendants staying at this hotel have reported seeing a ghostly flight attendant in the mirror and sitting on the edge of their beds. Rumor has it she was killed by a pilot at the hotel. Now known as the Magnuson Grand Hotel South Bend.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Tippecanoe Place

    South Bend, Indiana

    76.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    Tippecanoe Place is a restaurant within the Studebaker Mansion, once owned by Clement Studebaker of automobile fame. Studebaker's child and nanny were seriously injured when a fire broke out in the nursery and he killed himself not long after. Employees see things moving from the corner of their eye and ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Potato Creek State Park

    North Liberty, Indiana

    76.9 miles from New Haven, IN

    Potato Creek State Park has 327 acres of fields, woodlands, prairies and wetlands. It is said to be haunted by ghostly children who have drowned here while swimming or fishing over the years. The plaintive sound of a child crying or calling for its mother has been rumored to come ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    University of Notre Dame

    Notre Dame, Indiana

    77 miles from New Haven, IN

    "Win one for the Gipper" is a term that references the University of Notre Dame ghost George Gipp, a legendary Notre Dame footballer. His ghost is reputed to haunt Washington Hall ever since he died from strep throat in December 1920. He manifests as night noises and footsteps, slamming doors, ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Siena Heights University

    Adrian, Michigan

    77.5 miles from New Haven, IN

    Siena Heights University is rumored to have a haunted room in one of its dorms. At least, Room 211 is said to have been haunted in the 1970s. A witness reported that doors opened and closed, and glowing eyes came out of nowhere in the middle of a wall. A ...


    Read more »

  • Haunted Indiana 2
    Mark Marimen
  • 0

    Saint Mary's College - Le Mans Hall

    Notre Dame, Indiana

    78 miles from New Haven, IN

    A scary apparition of a girl hanging from a noose has been witnessed at the Le Mans Hall bell tower. Legend has it that she committed suicide in that very spot years ago. Also, the infirmary on the fourth floor is said to sport blood stains resulting from a girls' ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Dix - Fayerweather House

    Maumee, Ohio

    78 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Dix/Fayerweather House is said to be haunted by Aunt Phoebe, builder William Dix's sister. But be warened, Aunt Phoebe doesn't stand for disrespectful behavior. People who scoff at her may get a coffee shower or a door slammed nearby. A coat and chandelier crystals have gone missing, and an ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Linck Inn

    Maumee, Ohio

    78.8 miles from New Haven, IN

    This historic building was built in 1836, and has served as both a general store and as a hotel, as it was a popular stopover point for stagecoach and canal travellers. The hotel is no longer in operation, but is believed to still have three ghostly tenants who stayed on. ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Sullivan-Johnson Museum - Hardin County Historical Museum

    Kenton, Ohio

    79 miles from New Haven, IN

    The Sullivan-Johnson Museum, owned by the Hardin County Historical Museums, is in an 1896 private residence. It is believed to be haunted by former resident Mrs. Sullivan. Witnesses have seen her apparition on ghost tours and heard footsteps or smelled her perfume.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Roads Hotel

    Atlanta, Indiana

    79.3 miles from New Haven, IN

    The 1893 hotel, once patronized by John Dillinger, is rumored to be haunted by many spirits. Witnesses have reported shadows and apparitions of men, women and children as well as disembodied voices, footsteps, lights that work on their own, and doors that open and close--or even slam--by themselves.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hull-Wolcott House

    Maumee, Ohio

    79.4 miles from New Haven, IN

    This historic house, built in 1836 and now a museum complex, is home to some playful spirits who move objects and open doors. Witnesses also have heard unexplained footsteps and whispers.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Clark Lake Community Center

    Clarklake, Michigan

    81.4 miles from New Haven, IN

    It first happened Sunday, September 27, 2015, the night of the Blood Moon. While many around Clark Lake were gazing upward observing the astronomical phenomenon, a darker aberration was occurring. As if to say there was a morsel of truth to what are largely regarded as myths, the night of ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    National House Inn

    Marshall, Michigan

    83 miles from New Haven, IN

    This historic inn, built in 1835 by Colonel Andrew Mann and believed to have been a stop on the Underground Railroad, is said to be haunted by a Lady in Red. The ghost is usually seen only by a glimpse as she moves through the hallways, but has also been ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Anderson Cemetery

    Lawton, Michigan

    83.1 miles from New Haven, IN

    Anderson Cemetery has a legend that explains a glowing headstone. So the story goes, a man came to the Morris family home and shot the whole family and the maid, then stole a horse. The family was buried here, and on the anniversary of the murder, the headstone is said ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Thornhaven Manor

    New Castle, Indiana

    83.4 miles from New Haven, IN

    This curious haunt has been featured on Ghost Adventures and is quickly becoming one of the most talked about haunted locations for the innumerable amounts of paranormal activity occurring on the property. Sitting on seven acres this foreboding home is the site of murder, mysterious deaths, and rumored suicide. (Submitted ...


    Read more »


» Cemeteries near New Haven, IN

» Find museums in New Haven, IN