The McGarrah Stagecoach Tavern Inn

Monroe, NY · Restaurants and Bars

Featured on several ghost-related TV shows, this historic inn from the late 1700s is one of the oldest buildings in town. Here you may see a ghost in a top hat and dark suit. The inn may no longer be in operation but may be offering private tours by appointment only; one site gives this phone number to set up an appointment: (845) 783-6206.

Photo Gallery

Related Videos

Geographic Information

Address
300 Stage Road
Monroe, NY
Get Directions »
GPS
41.32477947, -74.18648854
County
Orange County, New York
Nearest Towns

Quick Answers

Is The McGarrah Stagecoach Tavern Inn really haunted?
Visitors rate The McGarrah Stagecoach Tavern Inn at 77.8 out of 100 on our EHP (Estimated Haunted Probability) scale. So far 5 people have shared firsthand experiences from this location in the comments.
Where is The McGarrah Stagecoach Tavern Inn located?
The address is 300 Stage Road, Monroe, NY. GPS coordinates: 41.32477947, -74.18648854.
What kind of haunted place is The McGarrah Stagecoach Tavern Inn?
The McGarrah Stagecoach Tavern Inn is listed under Restaurants and Bars in our New York section.
What is the nearest town to The McGarrah Stagecoach Tavern Inn?
Monroe, NY is the closest town, about 0.4 miles away, with Kiryas Joel (1.5 mi.) and Walton Park (2.4 mi.) also nearby.

Please note: It is your responsibility to acquire appropriate permissions before investigating any location listed on this site. Private property should be respected at all times, as should all posted signs concerning trespassing, hours of operation and other regulations.

Share Your Experiences

Comments (5)

  • DD |

    I 100% KNOW its Haunted! Never told anything about it and I got the shocker of my life (never told anything about it being haunted nor even gave it a thought) I seen lots and lots of shadow people all watching me as I was preparing to give a slide show presentation! Something I will never forget!

  • George Crinnion |

    It is an Inn built in 1799. It is now owned by the Cornerstone Masonic Historic Society and they so private tours for ghost investigators. The fee they charge is fax deductible so why not arrange for a ghost hunt of your own? Email me for details at gio10992@aol.com

    • George Crinnion |

      Tax deductible I meant lol... Sorry

  • June Newcomb |

    Went on one of the ghost hunts at the Inn. This is the picture I captured. Believe what you will.

  • MM |

    I can 100% vouch that this building has some pretty serious energy. I grew up in Monroe and my girl scout troop meetings were in this building. One of the badges is to stay overnight in a historic building and seeing as this is a historic Mason's lodge so we spent the night here. We went to parts of the house that were blocked off but didn't make it too far because we were all scared half to death.

Disclaimer: The stories posted here are user-submitted and are, in the truest sense, ghost stories. Haunted Places makes no claims that any of these stories are factually accurate or scientifically provable.