Is Historic Stoner House really haunted?

Visitors rate Historic Stoner House at 71.4 out of 100 on our EHP (Estimated Haunted Probability) scale. So far 14 people have shared firsthand experiences from this location in the comments.

Where is Historic Stoner House located?

The address is 133 S State St, Westerville, OH. GPS coordinates: 40.1223974, -82.9305664.

What kind of haunted place is Historic Stoner House?

Historic Stoner House is listed under Historical Buildings in our Ohio section.

What is the nearest town to Historic Stoner House?

Westerville, OH is the closest town, about 0.3 miles away, with Huber Ridge (2.4 mi.) and Minerva Park (3.3 mi.) also nearby.

Historic Stoner House - Westerville, OH

Mystic Nirvana / The Historic Stoner House - it was built in 1852 by George Stoner as an inn and tavern. It also was a station on the Underground Railroad. There was a 'hidden' room in the basement where the runaways would hide out till they could make their way up to the handy house or the Sharp house. There have been several people independent of one another witness a Shadow figure coming in the back door on the 2nd floor porch. There has also been photo evidence caught of a light anomaly and a strange mist. We have heard Voices and even captured several on recorder. Lady Was moping the floor and heard a man say "Doing a good Job" but no one was there but her. Lady witnessed seeing a full body apparition of a civil was soldier on a red house on the property. Have heard bells being jingled in the basement where the 'hidden' room was for the runaway slaves. During a class, a student witnessed a Full body apparition of a woman coming out of one of the rooms upstairs and going into the stair well on the second floor. (Submitted by Brenda Posani)

Photo Gallery

Share this Haunted Place

Geographic Information

Address

133 S State St
Westerville, OH
Get Directions »

GPS

40.1223974, -82.9305664

County

Franklin County County, Ohio

Nearest Towns

Westerville, OH (0.3 mi.)
Huber Ridge, OH (2.4 mi.)
Minerva Park, OH (3.3 mi.)
Worthington, OH (5.0 mi.)
Riverlea, OH (5.7 mi.)
Galena, OH (6.9 mi.)
New Albany, OH (7.0 mi.)
Gahanna, OH (7.6 mi.)
Powell, OH (8.0 mi.)
Cheshire, OH (8.2 mi.)

Quick Answers

Is Historic Stoner House really haunted?: Visitors rate Historic Stoner House at 71.4 out of 100 on our EHP (Estimated Haunted Probability) scale. So far 14 people have shared firsthand experiences from this location in the comments.
Where is Historic Stoner House located?: The address is 133 S State St, Westerville, OH. GPS coordinates: 40.1223974, -82.9305664.
What kind of haunted place is Historic Stoner House?: Historic Stoner House is listed under Historical Buildings in our Ohio section.
What is the nearest town to Historic Stoner House?: Westerville, OH is the closest town, about 0.3 miles away, with Huber Ridge (2.4 mi.) and Minerva Park (3.3 mi.) also nearby.

Please note: It is your responsibility to acquire appropriate permissions before investigating any location listed on this site. Private property should be respected at all times, as should all posted signs concerning trespassing, hours of operation and other regulations.

Share Your Experiences

Comments (14)

Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

Had deer cam on back porch of stoner house inn & tavern (Mystic Nirvana). Caught some unusual photos!
Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

another unusual photo taken by my deer can at the stoner house inn & tavern (Mystic Nirvana)
Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

Date and time are correct of deer cam pics. Old historic photo of stoner inn & tavern
Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

Deer cam photo weird lights
Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

Ufo? Westerville oh taken by deer am from Stoner house / mystic nirvana
Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

Same night ufo? Stoner house / Mystic Nirvana
Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

Same night 3D photo ufo? Stoner house / Mystic Nirvana
Brenda posani | September 21, 2016

4th photo ufo?
Brenda posani | March 20, 2017

light caught by deer cam
Brenda posani | March 20, 2017

Midst caught by deer cam off back porch of stoner house. By mystic nirvana
Brenda posani | March 20, 2017

Caught stage coach on camera at 2am out back of stoner house after investigating the basement where they his the slaves as part of the Underground Railroad. Stoner inn and tavern, was what the house was called back in 1852. George stoner drove a stage. Coach from columbus to westerville as a commitment they would stay at his inn.
Brenda posani | March 20, 2017

Directly after catching the stage coach on camera at 2am out back of stoner house snapped the camera again and got a woman in a long blue dress, black cape, black bonnet, carrying a black bag in her hand walking away from the stage coach. This was after investigating the basement where they his the slaves as part of the Underground Railroad. Stoner inn and tavern, was what the house was called back in 1852. George stoner drove a stage. Coach from columbus to westerville as a commitment they would stay at his inn.
Brenda posani | March 20, 2017

By the way there is also a darker skinned man in a large brown cowboy hat with a beard and mustache who has her by the arm escorting her around the house.
Dominique Powell | October 12, 2021

I just moved into this area being talked about in this story and after 4 days living there I had my 1st experience wt a ghost this morning!!!!Im trying to find more info out about it!!!!

Disclaimer: The stories posted here are user-submitted and are, in the truest sense, ghost stories. Haunted Places makes no claims that any of these stories are factually accurate or scientifically provable.