Haunted Places in Otterbein, Indiana



  • 0

    Harrison Cemetery

    West Lafayette, Indiana

    9.7 miles from Otterbein, IN

    At Harrison Cemetery, visitors have heard crying and moaning and had an eerie feeling that something is watching them. A few have been touched by something unseen or have had things thrown at them by invisible hands. Gravestones are said to move around here as well.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hotel Attica

    Attica, Indiana

    15.7 miles from Otterbein, IN

    A glowing apparition has been seen in several hotel rooms late at night or in the early hours of morning. Guests have reported seeing their closet doors open and close by themselves, as well as hearing ghostly voices and ballroom music. (Submitted by Callum Swift)


    Read more »
  • 0

    Attica Public Library

    Attica, Indiana

    15.9 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Built in 1905, the employees of this library have heard strange noises including knocking, whistling, whispering, dragging sounds, and even the sounds of the toys in the children's area moving by themselves after closing. The employees have also mentioned seeing figures watching them or shadows darting around. They ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Locust Grove Cemetery

    Ambia, Indiana

    18.2 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Phantom sounds of an army cadence and marching are heard at Locust Grove Cemetery. Legend has it that Harrison's ghostly men are re-creating the Battle of Tippecanoe.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hamilton Road

    Mulberry, Indiana

    27.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Stories about Hamilton Road are of the urban legend type. For example, a ghost of a short man will chase you if you stop on the third bridge and flash your lights four times, then cross the bridge. Phantom flames are said to come from the woods where an 1800s ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Saint Joseph's College

    Collegeville, Indiana

    29.8 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Some of the many oddities at St. Joseph's College include a spirit in the chapel, a rumored exorcism at Aquinas Hall and reports of witnesses hearing voices in their heads inside Drexel Hall. Also, Dwenger Hall is rumored to be possessed, and the ghost of a baby is said to ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Memory Gardens

    Rensselaer, Indiana

    31.6 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Memory Gardens is a cemetery with a haunted statue, locals claim. The saint statue at the back of the graveyard is rumored to move at night, keeping watch on visitors. Some say its head and arms will change position. However, the cemetery is closed after dark and trespassers will be ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Fischer Theater

    Danville, Illinois

    37.7 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Fischer Theater was a 19th century opera house located in Danville, IL that has served many purposes over the years including housing, stores, and of course, a theater. While now a generally unknown location, the Theater has been known to be haunted when a volunteer of the Vermillion Heritage ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Vennum House - The Watseka Wonder

    Watseka, Illinois

    38.4 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The Vennum House was the home of Lurancy Vennum, a teenaged epilectic girl who was said to have been possessed in the incident known as the Watseka Wonder. The story of the late-19th-century possession was related in the 2009 film "The Possessed." The house may be open for ghost tours ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Roff House - The Watseka Wonder

    Watseka, Illinois

    38.9 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The Roff House was one of the two houses in which the Watseka Wonder took place. The Watseka Wonder was a spiritual possession said to have happened in the late 19th century to an epileptic girl named Lurancy Vennum, who was 14 at the time. One of the spirits who ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Mount Hope Cemetery

    Logansport, Indiana

    42.7 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Phantom sounds of horses and whistles that echo your own have been reported in this cemetery that dates back to the 1800s. Also, some reports say there are mausoleums here with spooky inscriptions like "Knock three times and they shall come."


    Read more »
  • 0

    2220 N Armstrong St

    Kokomo, Indiana

    50.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    2220 N. Armstrong Kokomo Indiana is now an empty lot. There is no longer a home on the property. It was burned by a serial arsonist. He caused more than 22 structural fires in Kokomo. My childhood home was his last. The arsonist lived ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Old Jail Inn

    Rockville, Indiana

    50.8 miles from Otterbein, IN

    This 1879 former courthouse is now a bed and breakfast inn with a twist; it still retains many of its original features dating back to when it served as the town jailhouse. Guests sleeping in 'cells' have reported disembodied footsteps, a foreboding male voice and sightings of a male ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Dog Face Bridge

    La Crosse, Indiana

    53.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Spooky legends surround this old bridge. The stories involve a honeymooning 1950s couple and a dog that ran out in front of the car, causing them to drive off of the bridge. Reports of many things have been made in the vicinity, including apparitions of bodies, apparitions of a females ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Baums Bridge Inn

    Kouts, Indiana

    54.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    This inn is reported to be home to a the apparition of a man surrounded by a dim light. He is said to appear around midnight and may be a bit shy: Rumor has it that if you look at him too long, he will become enraged and appear in ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    O'Neal Bridge - Holiday Drive Bridge

    Zionsville, Indiana

    55.9 miles from Otterbein, IN

    O'Neal Bridge, aka Holiday Drive Bridge, was built around 1892 and restored in 2008-2009. The bridge may no longer be in use, according to reports. Legend has it that around this spot, a KKK lynching took place, and hauntings way stem from it. Witnesses have reported disembodied screams in the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Tillett Cemetery - Hookman's Cemetery

    Peru, Indiana

    58.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Tillett Cemetery is also known as Hookman's Cemetery because of a local tale of a ghostly man with a hook for a hand who prowls the nearby roads looking for victims. Thick, eerie fogs and cold spots are known to materialize in the area as well.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Lake Prairie Cemetery

    Lowell, Indiana

    58.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Apparitions of deceased townspeople, ghostly mists, and orbs all have been reported at this cemetery, especially in the southern half, which is the oldest.


    Read more »
  • 0

    City Tavern

    Kankakee, Illinois

    59.2 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Employees and diners at this popular restaurant and bar have reportedly encountered a male spirit. Known as 'David', patrons have had their hair pulled and have been pushed around by unseen hands. (Submitted by Callum Swift)


    Read more »
  • 0

    Majestic Theater

    Kankakee, Illinois

    59.2 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Dating back to 1912, the historic theater achieved notoriety when the 'Marx Brothers' performed a vaudeville act there in 1916. However, the theatre is also renowned for its ghostly inhabitants, including a ghostly child and Julia Remmington, a former owner. (Submitted by Callum Swift)


    Read more »
  • 0

    Roads Hotel

    Atlanta, Indiana

    59.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The 1893 hotel, once patronized by John Dillinger, is rumored to be haunted by many spirits. Witnesses have reported shadows and apparitions of men, women and children as well as disembodied voices, footsteps, lights that work on their own, and doors that open and close--or even slam--by themselves.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Avon Bridge

    Danville, Indiana

    59.7 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The Haunted Bridge of Avon is half mile south of U.S. Highway 36 on CR 625. It is said to be haunted by a ghost (or maybe two or three) who moans or cries tears onto the bridge. Some legends say it's Henry Johnson, a construction worker fond of the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Okie Pinokie

    Peru, Indiana

    61.6 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The Okie Pinokie Woods, according to local legend, are full of disembodied spirits. One of the many legends about the place centers on Joey Peoria, a young man who disappeared while camping in 1976. Brutally murdered men began showing up in the area, and folks say it was Joey who ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Avon Haunted Bridge

    Avon, Indiana

    62.1 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The Avon Haunted Bridge is a railroad bridge that was built in 1906, and legend has it that it's haunted. So the story goes, a mother was walking with her baby on the tracks when they fell to their deaths. Locals would say every time you drove under the bridge ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Boone-Hutcheson Cemetery

    Greencastle, Indiana

    63.1 miles from Otterbein, IN

    An apparition of a 1950s policeman is said to sit inside the graveyard with a blue light. Other apparitions and phantom dogs with glowing red eyes also have been seen, and a cave said to be on the cemetery premises has many spooky stories attached to it.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Manteno State Hospital

    Manteno, Illinois

    63.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The 1930s Manteno State Hospital suffered a typhoid fever epidemic in 1939, and more than 50 patients and staff members died. The hospital eventually was renamed the Manteno Mental Health Center; it ceased operations in 1985 and the complex became business rentals, a bank, part of the Illinois Diversatech Campus ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Crown Point Sheriff's House and Jail

    Crown Point, Indiana

    65.4 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The Crown Point Sheriff's House was built in 1882, and the jail was added on in 1926. This is the very jail from which John Dillinger made his notorious escape in 1934. He used jail-issued razor blades to carved a gun out of part of a wooden washboard. He used ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Inn at Aberdeen

    Valparaiso, Indiana

    65.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    A playful haunt at this 1830s-era inn has been known to hide guests' belongings in odd places. For example, one guest's missing lipstick turned up in a shoe. Cold spots and disembodied footsteps also have been reported, and psychic and ghost-hunting teams have determined that there are spirits of a ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    James Allison Mansion

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    66.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Built from 1911 to 1913, the mansion is said to be haunted. Sources may be a little girl who was visiting and drowned in the basement pool, or James Allison himself. The little girl's apparition has been seen, and witnesses also have reported voices in the attic, objects that move ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wheeler-Stokely Mansion

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    66.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Witnesses tell of an apparition of a man walking a dog and another ghost of a brunette woman who runs out a door and jumps into a phantom carriage. Some folks say they have been nudged off the dog walk, or had unexplained chills or uneasy feelings. Other apparitions have ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Valparaiso University

    Valparaiso, Indiana

    67.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    At the Alumni Hall at Valparaiso University, two ghost children, age 8 or 9 and wearing jogging pants, are known to run up and down the hallways at about 2 a.m. According to some of the student residents, the ghosts have spoken to them and told them they were playing ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Porter County Jail and Sheriff's House

    Valparaiso, Indiana

    67.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Porter County Jail and Sheriff's House is rumored to be haunted and has been used at Halloween for a haunted house attraction. Witnesses have described many strange occurrences including orbs of light and objects that turn up missing.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Markle Mill - Old Mill Dam

    North Terre Haute, Indiana

    67.8 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Markle Mill was the longest operating gristmill east of the Mississippi, and is rumored to have been part of the Underground Railroad, but all that remains of the original 1816 structure are the dam and parts of the foundation. The ghost girl who has been seen here is believed to ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Indiana Central State Hospital

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    68.4 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The 1848 Indiana Hospital for the Insane turned into the Central State Hospital in 1926. It is said to be haunted by many patients who suffered abuse here in the hospital's dark past. Witnesses have described shadows, apparitions, women's screams, electrical devices that turn on and off by themselves, unexplained ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Cloverdale Cemetery

    Cloverdale, Indiana

    69.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The 1800s Cloverdale Cemetery is rumored to have the graves of seven beautiful witch sisters. Many urban legends center on the sisters, such as that those who walk around their graves seven times by the light of a full moon would awaken the sisters' ghosts, which would chase them away. ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Indianapolis Athletic Club

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    70.1 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Built in the 1920s, the Indianapolis Athletic Club is believed to be haunted by the ghost of a fireman who attempts to wake up guests in the middle of the night. Reports say the man died in a fire that occurred here in 1992.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Indiana Repertory Theatre

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    70.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    To avoid cold and rainy weather, a former artistic director used to jog indoors, around the upstairs mezzanine. He was killed suddenly when his nephew hit him with the car as he was jogging on a foggy day. Now, on cold and rainy days, witnesses say you can hear the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Ax-Man's House - Ax-Man's Bridge

    Crete, Illinois

    70.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Legends told by locals say that in the 1970s, a man killed his wife, kids, and two policeman with an ax before hanging their bodies from meat hooks in his shed. When the police found out, he ran from them. The police gave pursuit and shot him in the woods ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Slippery Noodle Inn

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    70.6 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The historic buildings that house the Slippery Noodle have been around for a while, since 1850, so it has its share of spirits. Among those seen are the ghosts of slaves, a cowboy, a caretaker, and a prostitute.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Highland Lawn Cemetery

    Terre Haute, Indiana

    71.4 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Highland Lawn Cemetery has a couple ghostly legends. One is about Stiffy Green, a phantom bulldog. Stiffy Green belonged to John Heinl, a likable elderly man. The friendly dog was named for his stiff gait and bright-green eyes. When Heinl passed away in 1920, Stiffy Green refused to leave the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Rivoli Theatre

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    71.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The 1927 Rivoli Theatre is rumored to have been built atop Indian burial grounds. Witnesses have reported a wide array of hauntings that include apparitions, toilets that flush by themselves, faucets that turn on, a smoking cigarette butt that appeared in the ashtray out of nowhere, moving objects and things ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wolf Mansion - Josephus Wolf House

    Valparaiso, Indiana

    72.3 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Legend has it that the mansion owner went crazy after slavery was abolished, and in his rage, he killed all of his slaves and their children. Some stories say he even killed his family while he was at it. Then he killed himself. Now, folks say, an unexplained light comes ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Reeder Road

    Griffith, Indiana

    72.4 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Local lore about Reder Road tells of Elizabeth Wilson, a hitchhiking ghost who drowned in a swamp when her car went off the road. Her ghost waits at the roadside for a ride to her former house, but she disappears from cars at Ross Cemetery, where she was buried in ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Indiana State University

    Terre Haute, Indiana

    72.5 miles from Otterbein, IN

    At Indiana State University's Burford Hall, a ghost named Barb is the spirit of a student who died of alcohol poisoning. Witnesses have heard her vomiting or crying in the bathroom. And in Cromwell Hall is a white cross under a 12th-floor window where a man jumped to his death, ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Vigo County Historical Museum

    Terre Haute, Indiana

    73.6 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Formerly the Sage Mansion and once used as a halfway house, the Vigo County Historical Museum is home to some strange phenomena. The front staircase is a hot spot for orbs, and a small mist has been seen as well. Furthermore, a crib upstairs in an area that's closed to ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hannah House

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    73.7 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Some of the ghosts at this historic house are said to be hidden slaves, one of whom accidentally tripped over a lamp, igniting a house fire. Those killed were said to be buried in the very cellar where it happened. Witnesses have described a lot of activity in the cellar, ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hannah House

    Indianapolis, Indiana

    73.7 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The 1858 Hannah House, built by Alexander Hannah, was part of the Underground Railroad. Sadly, one night as a group of traveling slaves was sleeping, an oil lamp overturned and ignited the straw nearby, killing them all. Hannah buried their bodies in the cellar in an attempt to keep his ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Zion United Church Of Christ Cemetery

    Poland, Indiana

    73.8 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The spooky sort love Zion Church Cemetery, say locals. The area is a hot spot for unexplained lights and sounds, ghostly whispers, eerie sensations, and the feeling of being watched. Some say a helpful ghost is known to leave the cemetery to stop cars and tell folks to turn back ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Carolina Street Demon House

    Gary, Indiana

    74.1 miles from Otterbein, IN

    The house was said to be haunted by more than 200 demons. Witnesses have reported levitating children, swarms of flies that mysteriously appear in winter, footprints, and apparitions. The demons were believed to have possessed the three children of the family who lived there, and case workers, priests and police ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Ivy House

    Fortville, Indiana

    75.9 miles from Otterbein, IN

    Built in 1921 by Dr. Jess E. Ferrell, the Ivy House bed-and-breakfast inn is said to have a haunt that came with the purchase of an antique piano. The owners say the instrument brought with it a ghost who makes the decidely nonmusical sounds of banging and walking footsteps.


    Read more »

  • Haunted Indiana 2
    Mark Marimen

    Haunted Indiana 3
    Mark Marimen


» Cemeteries near Otterbein, IN

» Find museums in Otterbein, IN