Haunted Places in Potter County, Pennsylvania

    We're sorry, but there are currently no haunted listings available within the boundaries of Potter County, Pennsylvania. If you know of one that should be listed here, please let us know via our submission form. Alternatively, you may want to expand your search to the state of Pennsylvania.

    In the meantime, here's a list of all haunted places within 100 miles of Potter County, Pennsylvania.

  • 0

    The Old Jail Museum

    Smethport, Pennsylvania

    28.8 miles from Potter County, PA

    Ralph Crossmire, executed for murdering his mother, haunts his former cell. People who occupied it after his death would report seeing him. Now, as a museum, guests and employees report that Crossmire is more of a prankster than a threat. (Submitted by Chris Berglund)

  • 0

    Alfred University

    Alfred, New York

    35.5 miles from Potter County, PA

    Alfred University is rumored to be haunted by several ghosts. Among them are a Civil War soldier who walks the hallways of The Brick, which was once used as a Civil War infirmary. Other ghosts rumored to linger here are a little boy who appears on the second floor of ...

  • 0

    St. Bonaventure University

    Olean, New York

    37.6 miles from Potter County, PA

    St. Bonaventure University has more than its share of campus ghosts. Francis Hall, once called Christ the King Seminary, is said to be haunted by the spirits of deceased monks. Devereux Hall is famous for stories of its Black Mass. Legend has it that in the 1960s, the students gathered ...

  • 0

    Beech Creek Furst Corner

    Beech Creek, Pennsylvania

    48.9 miles from Potter County, PA

    It's not only your eyes and ears that may detect haunted happenings here, but your nose may get in on the action too. Folks say at this restaurant you can smell ghostly cigar smoke from its old days. So the story goes, former owner Mr. Furst died in a fire ...

  • 0


    Clearfield, Pennsylvania

    55 miles from Potter County, PA

    I was an opening GM before when it had lost its flag from a Ramada. I was in the back of the back closet and there were just 2 people in the building the front desk person and I was getting food for the downtown pantry and trying to organize ...

  • 0

    Elmira College

    Elmira, New York

    60.7 miles from Potter County, PA

    Spookiness abounds at Elmira College, some say. Take Cowles Hall, where some say eerie lights float down hallways and whispering comes from nowhere. Some believe the building is split down the middle, with one good and one evil half. And an empty fourth-floor room of Tompkins Hall is rumored to ...

  • 0

    Lindenwald Haus

    Elmira, New York

    61.3 miles from Potter County, PA

    Lindenwald Haus has been housing aged and destitute men, women and orphans for 140 years. As the need to house civil war widows waned the owner entered into an agreement with the city of Elmira to provide housing and shelter for local residents. The original charter for the building was to ...

  • 0

    Naples Hotel

    Naples, New York

    65.2 miles from Potter County, PA

    Naples Hotel was built in 1895 and is rumored to be haunted by 6 or more ghosts. One is a man named Topper; another is a woman who has her ghostly children in tow. According to witnesses, the ghosts like to lock doors, turn on the lights, and move pictures ...

  • 0

    Penn State University

    State College, Pennsylvania

    65.4 miles from Potter County, PA

    Several buildings at Penn State University are allegedly haunted, including Pattee Library, said to be visited by the spirit of Betsy Aardsma, stabbed to death in the stacks in 1969. Schwab Auditorium is haunted by a former university president (who, incidentally, also haunts the Botany department building) as well as ...

  • 0

    Garrett Memorial Chapel

    Keuka Park, New York

    65.7 miles from Potter County, PA

    The sixth-century Norman Gothic-style Garrett Memorial Chapel, aka Little Chapel on the Mount, was constructed by Evelyn and Paul Garrett in memory of their son Charles, who died of tuberculosis in 1929. It is allegedly haunted by at least three ghosts: A priest, a boy, and a woman. Witnesses describe ...

  • 0

    Western House

    Springville, New York

    66.2 miles from Potter County, PA

    Western House, which reports say is currently unoccupied, was a hotel and saloon turned into apartments and a restaurant. A ghost called Christine is said to reside here. Folks in the know claim she is the daughter of a former owner.

  • 0

    Allegiance Bed and Breakfast

    Mount Morris, New York

    67.5 miles from Potter County, PA

    The historic 1838 building that houses Allegiance Bed & Breakfast and once was an overflow house for the Underground Railroad is believed to be home to two ghosts: Karen and Ray. They have been seen by guests three times, all on the second floor. Karen sits in a corner or ...

  • 0

    State University of New York Geneseo

    Geneseo, New York

    72.9 miles from Potter County, PA

    At State University of New York's Blake and Steuben halls, witnesses say apparitions can be seen and unexplained noises can be heard. Some speculate the buildings are haunted by a boy who fell to his death during construction of the buildings. And Monroe Hall is also believed to be haunted ...

  • 0

    Keuka College - Ball Hall

    Keuka Park, New York

    72.9 miles from Potter County, PA

    Ball Hall at Keuka College is rumored to be a hot spot for the spirit set. George Harvey Ball himself, the college's founder and original president, is the one believed to be doing the haunting. Witnesses say TV's turn off by themselves, beds move, and a ghostly woman's voice has ...

  • 0

    Erie Hall - SUNY Geneseo

    Geneseo, New York

    73 miles from Potter County, PA

    A famous image of the C2D1 Ghost or Skeletal Image comes from this dorm, room C2D1. In 1985, the ghost named Tommy was said to haunt some Erie Hall residents, and the shot was snapped. This photo has been seen on the Internet, in books, in newspapers, on TV, and ...

  • 0

    Newell Road Spook Hill

    Middlesex, New York

    73.3 miles from Potter County, PA

    Along Newell Road is Spook Hill, a place well known in local lore. Pass the top of the big hill until you see a driveway on the right and the Spike Road sign on the left. Stop and put your car in neutral and your car will roll backward up ...

  • 0

    Goose Hill Cemetery - Saint Johns Cemetery

    Strykersville, New York

    74.2 miles from Potter County, PA

    Goose Hill Cemetery, aka Saint Johns Cemetery, dates back to around the turn of the 20th century. It consists of about 30 gravesites on a hill, surrounded by a forest. Witnesses have spotted apparitions and heard disembodied voices that seem to come from the forest.

  • 0

    Goodleburg Cemetery

    South Wales, New York

    74.6 miles from Potter County, PA

    Goodleburg Cemetery was an active cemetery from 1811 until 1927 and is believed to be haunted. Apparitions and other paranormal occurrences have been reported here, and in fact, on the night of June 21, 2003, a ghost hunter investigating the cemetery was hit by a car and killed. According to ...

  • 0

    Old Morton Salt Plant

    Himrod, New York

    75.5 miles from Potter County, PA

    This former Morton Salt Plant is reported to have closed after several cave-ins crushed and killed workers. The abandoned plant is said to be haunted by the spirits of deceased employees and ghostly mining cars that still travel through the plant.

  • 0

    The Lady in Granite

    Penn Yan, New York

    76.2 miles from Potter County, PA

    The Lady in Granite appears on a gravestone for the Gillette family. It is an image of a lady's head, reclining, thought to be the head of Matilda Gillette. No amount of polishing has been able to remove the image from the stone. According to local legend, eventually her whole ...

  • 0

    Miles Wine Cellars

    Himrod, New York

    78.2 miles from Potter County, PA

    Miles Wine Cellars, a winery and inn, has made its own wine in honor of its ghosts. Called Ghost, it is a blend of Chardonnay and Cayuga wines. The place is haunted by a ghost that has manifested as a mist that slams doors. Actually, legend has it that there ...

  • 0

    Roycroft Pavilion

    East Aurora, New York

    79.4 miles from Potter County, PA

    The Roycroft Pavilion, built in 1903, has been used as a theater for the Aurora Players since 1941. According to the pavilion's staff, the theater is haunted by the ghost of a middle-aged woman with dark hair.

  • 0

    Roycroft Inn

    East Aurora, New York

    79.7 miles from Potter County, PA

    Footsteps, voices and apparitions are all heard and seen at the Roycroft Inn. Some people believe that it is haunted by Elbert Hubbard who founded the Roycroft campus and building in an effort to encourage and promote local artistry. Elbert died on the Lusitania when it was sunk ...

  • 0

    Belhurst Castle

    Geneva, New York

    89.1 miles from Potter County, PA

    Reportedly haunted by a "white lady" apparition, Belhurst boasts a colorful past that urban legend has richly embellished. Many attribute the haunting to the ghost of an opera singer who died there. Some even further embellish the tale by claiming she died while attempting to escape from her ...

  • 0

    Riverside Cabaret

    Port Trevorton, Pennsylvania

    90 miles from Potter County, PA

    Riverside Cabaret (previously called "Wild J's") has had several paranormal events that occur almost weekly. Orbs have been seen both live and recorded on CCTV. Several staff have reported an hearing a male voice talk to them, a woman's sobbing is constantly heard in the basement, and many ...