Haunted Places in Crystal Beach, New York



  • 0

    Newell Road Spook Hill

    Middlesex, New York

    7.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Along Newell Road is Spook Hill, a place well known in local lore. Pass the top of the big hill until you see a driveway on the right and the Spike Road sign on the left. Stop and put your car in neutral and your car will roll backward up ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Sutherland House

    Canandaigua, New York

    7.4 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Locals once referred to this house as "The Haunted House" due to its state of disrepair and shabby appearance. It is now fixed up and runs as a bed and breakfast but there doesn't seem to be anything ghostly happening there.


    Read more »
  • 0

    New Michigan Road

    Farmington, New York

    10.5 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Another "Lady in White" story takes place here, on New Michigan Road in Victor, NY. The story goes that some newlyweds were killed here in a carriage accident long ago, and the spirit of the woman now lingers, ever searching for her lost husband.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Clifton Springs Sanitarium

    Clifton Springs, New York

    12.1 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The 5-story Clifton Springs Sanitarium was built in 1892 to promote Dr. Henry Foster's Clifton Springs Water Cure. It houses a chapel with a glass mosaic of "The Last Supper" designed by Louis Comfort Tiffany. The ghost of Dr. Foster has been seen sitting in the downstairs lobby of the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hobart and William Smith Colleges

    Geneva, New York

    14.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Many spooky tales are told about Hobart and William Smith Colleges, a couple of them originating in Hirshson Hall. In Room 304, for example, objects are said to fly off shelves, the blinds pull down by themselves, mysterious sounds of scratching and tapping are heard and apparitions have been seen ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Lady in Granite

    Penn Yan, New York

    14.6 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The Lady in Granite appears on a gravestone for the Gillette family. It is an image of a lady's head, reclining, thought to be the head of Matilda Gillette. No amount of polishing has been able to remove the image from the stone. According to local legend, eventually her whole ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Belhurst Castle

    Geneva, New York

    14.7 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Reportedly haunted by a "white lady" apparition, Belhurst boasts a colorful past that urban legend has richly embellished. Many attribute the haunting to the ghost of an opera singer who died there. Some even further embellish the tale by claiming she died while attempting to escape from her ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Naples Hotel

    Naples, New York

    15.5 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Naples Hotel was built in 1895 and is rumored to be haunted by 6 or more ghosts. One is a man named Topper; another is a woman who has her ghostly children in tow. According to witnesses, the ghosts like to lock doors, turn on the lights, and move pictures ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Keuka College - Ball Hall

    Keuka Park, New York

    16.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Ball Hall at Keuka College is rumored to be a hot spot for the spirit set. George Harvey Ball himself, the college's founder and original president, is the one believed to be doing the haunting. Witnesses say TV's turn off by themselves, beds move, and a ghostly woman's voice has ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Valentown Museum

    Victor, New York

    17 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    This haunted museum was originally a home built by Levi Valentine in 1879. It is believed to be inhabited by spirits who move tools in the basement, play an old-fashioned music box, and show up as apparitions or shadows. EVP have been captured here as well.


    Read more »

  • Haunted Southern Tier (NY)
    Elizabeth Tucker
  • 0

    Palmyra Historical Museum

    Palmyra, New York

    17.4 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    At this location in 1964, a mother and her six children died in a house fire. The museum is located on top of the site where the house burnt down. The children play around the museum and have been spoken to during ghost hunts. Other paranormal activity includes items ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    William Phelps General Store

    Palmyra, New York

    17.4 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    At the William Phelps General Store and Palmyra Historical Museum, folks have reported apparitions, ghostly whispers, footsteps, and touches from unseen hands. Ghost cats and images that turn up in photographs also have been experienced.


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Green Lantern Inn

    Fairport, New York

    21.7 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Now being used a banquet hall for weddings and other receptions, if you are looking for an overnight stay, this "Inn" has no accommodations. There is however a public restaurant on site if you are hoping to catch some ghostly activity. Reportedly haunted by the original owner, Henry ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Miles Wine Cellars

    Himrod, New York

    22 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Miles Wine Cellars, a winery and inn, has made its own wine in honor of its ghosts. Called Ghost, it is a blend of Chardonnay and Cayuga wines. The place is haunted by a ghost that has manifested as a mist that slams doors. Actually, legend has it that there ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Garrett Memorial Chapel

    Keuka Park, New York

    22.2 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The sixth-century Norman Gothic-style Garrett Memorial Chapel, aka Little Chapel on the Mount, was constructed by Evelyn and Paul Garrett in memory of their son Charles, who died of tuberculosis in 1929. It is allegedly haunted by at least three ghosts: A priest, a boy, and a woman. Witnesses describe ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Old Morton Salt Plant

    Himrod, New York

    22.4 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    This former Morton Salt Plant is reported to have closed after several cave-ins crushed and killed workers. The abandoned plant is said to be haunted by the spirits of deceased employees and ghostly mining cars that still travel through the plant.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Seneca Falls Historical Museum

    Seneca Falls, New York

    24.8 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Seneca Falls Historical Museum includes the mansion built in 1855 by Edward Mynderse, who is believed to reside here still despite his death long ago. Legend has it that when Mrs. Leroy (Ellen) Partridge bought the place in 1875 and began to alter it, Edward was unhappy. And to show ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Smith-Ely Mansion

    Clyde, New York

    27.2 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Built around 1850, the Smith-Ely Mansion is said to be home to ghosts of former inhabitants and more recent suicide victims.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Rochester Abandoned Psychiatric Center

    Rochester, New York

    27.6 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Although I've heard a lot about Rochester's abandoned buildings, I hadn't been to any of them out of apprehension and a little bit of fear. This one day that I did go, I brought my camera to try to capture the decaying architecture of the places. There are a ton of ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    State University of New York Geneseo

    Geneseo, New York

    28.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    At State University of New York's Blake and Steuben halls, witnesses say apparitions can be seen and unexplained noises can be heard. Some speculate the buildings are haunted by a boy who fell to his death during construction of the buildings. And Monroe Hall is also believed to be haunted ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Erie Hall - SUNY Geneseo

    Geneseo, New York

    28.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    A famous image of the C2D1 Ghost or Skeletal Image comes from this dorm, room C2D1. In 1985, the ghost named Tommy was said to haunt some Erie Hall residents, and the shot was snapped. This photo has been seen on the Internet, in books, in newspapers, on TV, and ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    University of Rochester - Rush Rhees Library

    Rochester, New York

    28.5 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Rush Rhees Library at the University of Rochester was named after the university's third president Benjamin Rush Rhees. It still houses the original elevator from when it was dedicated in 1930. The library's stacks are allegedly haunted by a workman who fell during construction in 1929.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Steph's Pond Nudist Park

    Williamson, New York

    28.6 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    We're not able to give out the exact location of this nudist resort (for obvious reasons), but if you're truly interested in visiting you can always contact them for an invitation via their web site link, below. (It's invites-only there.) The story goes that visitors to the retreat often hear ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Aurora Inn

    Aurora, New York

    28.7 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Haunted by a typical White Lady type haunting, this apparition is said to appear throughout the inn. In addition a male ghost is spied occasionally along the lake shoreline near the Inn.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Auditorium Theatre

    Rochester, New York

    29 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The Auditorium Theatre was built in 1928 as a Masonic temple. Now a venue for Broadway shows, it is also a haven for ghosts. Witnesses have noticed things moving backstage and spotted an apparition of an elderly man. Another ghost in a red coat has been seen in the lobby ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wells College

    Aurora, New York

    29.1 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Wells College has an abundance of ghost stories. Among the spirits said to live on campus are Morgan Hall's Max, a security guard who died in a fire; a female student in Zabriskie Hall who was stabbed to death by a professor who stole her research; vengeful Mrs. Wells, who ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Main Street Armory

    Rochester, New York

    29.1 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Main Street Armory, built in 1905 by the U.S. Army for the training and processing soldiers, remained in use until 1990. It was vacant until the mid-2000s, when witnesses began to report apparitions, moving objects, and more strange happenings. Folks say the armory is haunted by a ghost boy. The ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Rochester Public Library

    Rochester, New York

    29.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Rochester Public Library, according to witnesses, has spooks in its stacks. Rumor has it that it's haunted by a young woman who drowned when she fell in to an aqueduct (her body was wedged into a tunnel under the library) and by a former librarian named Frank, who had a ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Butcher Hill

    Interlaken, New York

    29.7 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Butcher Hill is a small hill in Lodi, NY, popular with trail hikers. Some who visit it though claim to hear the eerie sound of children playing, when obviously no children are anywhere around.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Allegiance Bed and Breakfast

    Mount Morris, New York

    31.4 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The historic 1838 building that houses Allegiance Bed & Breakfast and once was an overflow house for the Underground Railroad is believed to be home to two ghosts: Karen and Ray. They have been seen by guests three times, all on the second floor. Karen sits in a corner or ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Durand Eastman Park

    Rochester, New York

    32.6 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The White Lady, a phantom seen here, is reported to be the ghost of a mother whose daughter was murdered by her boyfriend. She is said to protect women here, only harassing men, especially those who may be mistreating women. She wears all white, and some reports say she shows ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Holy Sepulchre Cemetery

    Rochester, New York

    33.2 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The circa-1871 Holy Sepulchre Cemetery's claim to fame is that it's where Jack the Ripper suspect Francis Tumblety is buried. Witnesses say they have seen dark shadow women about the grounds, as well as plaintive white figures in the children's area.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Connecticut Hill Cemetery

    Crystal Beach, New York

    43 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    This area is rumored to be the home of a group of migratory Sasquatch, or Bigfoot, creatures as well as the site of many UFO sightings, but the Connecticut Hill Cemetery ghosts don't seem to be afraid. Witnesses have seen orbs, human shapes, shadows and strange mists while visiting the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wayside Irish Pub

    Elbridge, New York

    44 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Here you may see the ghost of a soldier from the Revolutionary War, who haunts the second floor, or the friendly spirit of a traveler nicknamed George, who once had a heart attack on either the second or third floor.


    Read more »
  • 0

    State University of New York Brockport - Hartwell Hall

    Brockport, New York

    44 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Hartwell Hall at the State University of New York Brockport is rumored to be haunted. The ghost may be Edward P. Rowley, who was a resident in 1888. According to an old newspaper report, he fell through some planks covering a cistern and became trapped, drowning in the seven feet ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Rolling Hills Asylum

    Wyoming, New York

    44.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Rolling Hills Asylum opened in 1827 as the Genesee County Poor Farm, made to house the poor, drunkards, mentally ill, blind, disabled, or other folks who needed help. In the 1950s it became the Old County Home & Infirmary, then in the 1990s an antiques mall. Store owners and shoppers ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Alfred University

    Alfred, New York

    47.1 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Alfred University is rumored to be haunted by several ghosts. Among them are a Civil War soldier who walks the hallways of The Brick, which was once used as a Civil War infirmary. Other ghosts rumored to linger here are a little boy who appears on the second floor of ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Whiskey Hollow Road

    Memphis, New York

    48.7 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Whiskey Hollow Road is a dark forest road, about 5 miles long, that has many urban legends attached to it, including that of satanic rituals, KKK practices and ghosts. One local legend says a man and his wife are two of the ghosts who roam these parts. The man was ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    West Main Street Cemetery Site

    Batavia, New York

    49 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The first graveyard in Batavia dated back to 1806. It was known as the West Main Street Cemetery, and was located along the northern banks of the Tonawanda Creek. The town founders didn't realize the extent to which the Tonawanda Creek regularly flooded, however, and in 1823 it ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Jacksonville Rural Cemetery

    Phoenix, New York

    50.9 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    A black cat with green glowing eyes, an apparition of a teen girl, and gunshots are some of the eerie things visitors have witnessed at the Jacksonville Rural Cemetery. To add to the eeriness, rumor has it that behind the cemetery is a forest with a stream that seems to ...


    Read more »

  • Ghosts of Manhattan
    Tara Leigh Parks
  • 0

    Brickyards

    Warners, New York

    51.5 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    This area of Camillus is famous for its Onondaga Brick. One of the brick yards here is also infamous for being haunted - some say by a gargoyle. Locals, however, are a bit mystified by the stories. While they admit the brick yards can be a little ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    13 Curves Road - Cedarville Road

    Nedrow, New York

    53 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    13 Curves Road, aka Cedarville Road, is known for a ghostly Bloody Bride. According to her legend, it was more than a century ago when a horrific car accident took the life of a newlywed couple on their wedding night. Their car veered off the road on one of its ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Walnut West Apartments

    Camillus, New York

    53.4 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Local legend says that one of the Walnut West Apartments is haunted and tenants tend to move out immediately. The ghost is said to be a little girl who was killed on the same spot when the land that now holds the apartment complex was a farm.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Lindenwald Haus

    Elmira, New York

    53.5 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Lindenwald Haus has been housing aged and destitute men, women and orphans for 140 years. As the need to house civil war widows waned the owner entered into an agreement with the city of Elmira to provide housing and shelter for local residents. The original charter for the building was to ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Split Rock Quarry

    Camillus, New York

    53.7 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Split Rock Quarry was a hazardous munitions plant that suddenly exploded in 1918, killing more than 50 men. Left today are nothing but rock and The Crusher, an defunct piece of mining machinery. Witnesses say the place is haunted by the past victims, citing unexplained voices and footsteps, and the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Elmira College

    Elmira, New York

    54.5 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Spookiness abounds at Elmira College, some say. Take Cowles Hall, where some say eerie lights float down hallways and whispering comes from nowhere. Some believe the building is split down the middle, with one good and one evil half. And an empty fourth-floor room of Tompkins Hall is rumored to ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Beechwood Cemetary

    Kendall, New York

    55 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    My husband and I pulled onto Woodchuck Alley and found an old cemetery there. We were the only two people there and it was a quiet, sunny, Sunday afternoon. My husband was at the far end of the cemetery closer to West Kendall Road and I was in ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Pillars Estate

    Albion, New York

    56.3 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    The Pillars Estate is a Victorian mansion built in the early 1800s. Here, a recreation of the story of Titanic is put on every April. Ghost hunting is not allowed, and overnight guests have to sign a waiver saying they will not conduct séances or otherwise disturb the ghosts who ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    SUNY College at Cortland

    Cortland, New York

    56.7 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    State University of New York Cortland is no stranger to the spirit world. Rumor has it that the ghost of a bleeding football player appears every year in Clark Hall's Room 716. And at Brockway Hall, the ghost of a former cook has appeared standing at the top of the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Ancestor's Inn at the Bassett House

    Liverpool, New York

    56.9 miles from Crystal Beach, NY

    Lights go on and off and photographs come out blank here. There is said to be a spirit named Tim who lives on the second floor. He shows himself most often when someone is not feeling well. Note: The inn may not currently be in operation.


    Read more »


» Cemeteries near Crystal Beach, NY

» Find museums in Crystal Beach, NY