Haunted Places in East Millstone, New Jersey



  • 0

    Hageman Farm

    Franklin Township, New Jersey

    2.6 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Hageman Farm is a historic house first settled by Catherine and Adrian Hegeman from the Netherlands in 1650 or 1651. It was occupied by relatives until 1972, then stood empty for 5 years until it was purchased and restored by the Meadows Foundation. Reports say an apparition of an elderly ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Abandoned Warehouses

    Bridgewater, New Jersey

    4.1 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    This abandoned building has been reported to have an evil entity that will chase you out of the building and slam doors while you are inside it. There is also a women that will stand by the open window in the back, she screams that "he is after her" ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Van Wickle House

    Franklin Township, New Jersey

    4.8 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The Van Wickle House was a wedding present for Evert and Cornelia Van Wickle, but tragically, they died on the same day the house was presented to them March 3, 1757. They are buried nearby on a hill, under some trees. The house is said to be haunted by Evert ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wallace House and Old Dutch Parsonage

    Somerville, New Jersey

    5.1 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The Old Dutch Parsonage was built in 1751 and was moved around 1913 to its present location, next door to the 1775 Wallace House. The Parsonage is said to be extremely haunted, with screams, banging, and objects being moved around at night. The Wallace House also is said to have ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Raritan Public Library

    Raritan, New Jersey

    5.3 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The historic Raritan Public Library is said to be haunted by a former librarian. Lights have been known to turn on and off by themselves, and books move on their own. Even more spooky, locals have seen the apparition of an elderly woman in the window and also in the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Neshanic Inn - Murphy's Crocodile Inn

    Neshanic Station, New Jersey

    7.8 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Formerly Murphy's Crocodile Inn but now the Neshanic Inn, the 1880s building experiences electrical malfunctions and a shadowy figure in the basement. The inn is located at 102 Woodfern Rd., near the post office and the colorful train station.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Dunellen Hotel

    Dunellen, New Jersey

    8.8 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    One guest here claims to have captured a ghostly image of a Victorian woman and boy on her iPhone while in the rathskeller (basement bar). (Submitted by Marlene B.)


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Devil's Tree

    Bernards, New Jersey

    8.9 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    This tree is said to have once been a meeting point, a headquarters and lynching spot used by the Ku Klux Klan. The Bernards Township tree allegedly will give off warmth, even in winter, and consequently, snow will not pile up on it as it does on other trees. According ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Piscatawaytown Burial Ground

    Edison, New Jersey

    9.7 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Piscatawaytown Burial Ground is a graveyard that holds the burial sites of many Revolutionary War soldiers and other folk; graves date back to 1693, when two brothers died from eating poisonous mushrooms. But the graveyard also houses a witch, locals say. Mary Moore, buried here in 1731, was accused and ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Ayers-Allen House

    Metuchen, New Jersey

    11.8 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The Ayers-Allen House is a private residence that dates back to the 1700s. It is believed to be haunted. Witnesses say the ghosts who live here are Revolutionary War or Hessian soldiers or a woman searching for her young son who was killed by British soldiers. Also said to be ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Union Hotel

    Flemington, New Jersey

    14.6 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Reports say the historic 1814 hotel is currently under plans for redevelopment. Witnesses claim to have seen ghosts of small children and poltergeist activity in the building, and one person reported seeing a pair of shoes walking up a staircase.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Old Bernardsville Public Library

    Bernardsville, New Jersey

    15 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Old Bernardsville Public Library was built in 1710 as the Vealtown Tavern during the American Revolution. It is said to be haunted by Phyllis Parker, whose father owned the Vealtown Tavern. She was in love with a doctor who was hanged for treason during the Revolutionary War. Not knowing what ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Proprietary House

    Perth Amboy, New Jersey

    16.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The 1762 Proprietary House was the home of William Franklin, son of Benjamin Franklin, New Jersey's last royal Governor from 1762 to 1777. It is said to be haunted by ghosts of a Revolutionary War soldier, a woman who stands in the dining room window, and a little boy in ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Conference House - Billop House

    East Millstone, New York

    17.3 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The Conference House, aka Billop House, was built in 1680. It was the scene of a tragedy when in 1779 owner Christopher Billop, a British loyalist, accused a female servant of spying on him for the Colonists. She denied the charge, and Billop threw her down the stairs, breaking her ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Hanging Post

    Cranford, New Jersey

    17.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    At the corner of Gallows Hill Road and Brookside Place once stood the giant hanging tree, where Revolutionary War spies were hanged. Although the tree is gone now, locals say you can still see ghostly movement here from a distance.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Kreischer Mansion

    East Millstone, New York

    18.1 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Kreischer Mansion has been on the market for a couple years now, sources say. A cool $8.5 million will buy it, and the ghost is included. According to the home's history, original builder German brickmaker Balthasar Kreischer died one year after the house was finished, and his son Edward died ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Historic Old Bermuda Inn

    Staten Island, New York

    19.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Believed to be haunted by the home's original mistress Martha Mesereau whose husband died fighting the Civil War. Legend has it that her restless spirit continues to occupy the former mansion, waiting endlessly for her husband to return to her. People see her in the dining room (which was ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Domani's Restaurant

    Roselle Park, New Jersey

    19.5 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    This restaurant, housed in a building that dates back to the 1880s, was said to be haunted by a former owner who died inside the building. The place was once featured on an episode of TV's Ghost Hunters. However, the location burned down in April 2009.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Drew University

    Madison, New Jersey

    19.7 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Many hauntings have been described at Drew University; for instance, in the Great Hall, which is quite like a castle, ghostly faces are said to appear in the ceiling carvings as the chandeliers swing by themselves. Also, a mirror reflects an apparition of a man in gold round spectacles. At ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Red Mill Museum

    Clinton, New Jersey

    19.7 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Red Mill Museum Village, recreating an 1810 mill, is haunted by an apparition who many tourists believe is a hired re-enactor on the third floor. The old man wears period clothing and a black hat and he doesn't speak. But the museum does not hire re-enactors, so if you see ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wolfe's Pond Park

    East Millstone, New York

    20.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Wolfe’s Pond Park, according to some, is haunted by the ghosts of two teens who perished in a nearby car crash. Local legend says the teens can be seen along the park paths at around 2 a.m., often calling for their parents.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Fairleigh Dickinson University

    Madison, New Jersey

    20.5 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Fairleigh Dickinson University has haunts in two halls, according to campus legend. In Lenfel Hall, witnesses have seen an apparition of founder Peter Sanmartino, and lights turn on and off on their own. And at the Mansion, many have seen a ghostly girl dancing in a white dress.


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Publick House

    Chester, New Jersey

    20.6 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Originally the 1810 Brick Hotel, the Publick House is said to be haunted by apparitions, growling noises, cold spots, phantom perfumes, and more eerie phenomena.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Caldwell Parsonage

    Union, New Jersey

    20.8 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Caldwell Parsonage dates to 1730 and was home to Rev. James Caldwell, a Presbyterian minister and patriot cause during the Revolutionary War. In 1780 during the Battle of Connecticut Farms, Caldwell's wife Hannah was killed in the living room by British soldiers, and one year later, Caldwell was shot by ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Marlboro Psychiatric Hospital

    Marlboro Township, New Jersey

    21.1 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Marlboro Psychiatric Hospital opened in early 1931 and operated for many years, but not without problems. Rampant deaths at the hospital were frequently being investigated. An adjacent cemetery holds nearly 1,000 graves. Over 130 patients became ill from food poisoning in the 1970s, four of whom died. The hospital was ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Inn of the Hawke

    Lambertville, New Jersey

    21.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    At this 1860s inn there are quite a few ghosts, according to witnesses. Odd noises and occurrences abound here; for example, in the kitchen, pots and pans may lift off their hooks and crash to the floor. Pictures also are often knocked off of the walls throughout the inn.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Trenton Psychiatric Hospital

    Trenton, New Jersey

    21.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    A man named Henry Cotton took over as the main doctor in 1907, but his methods were inhumane. He'd remove teeth, limbs, and organs because he believed that they had an involvement with mental illness. However, by removing stomachs, colons, and other vital organs, he had a high mortality rate, ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Inn At Phillips Mill

    New Hope, Pennsylvania

    21.7 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Built in the 1750s, this inn is said to be haunted by a lovely female who appears in great detail, sitting in a rocking chair in refined clothing. She also brushes past people on the stairs.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Logan Inn

    New Hope, Pennsylvania

    21.7 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    One of the oldest inns in America, the Logan Inn has a whole host of ghosts. It was in operation through the Revolutionary and Civil Wars. People have claimed to see an American Revolutionary war era soldier beating his ghostly drum through the hotel. In addition people ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Aaron Burr House

    New Hope, Pennsylvania

    21.9 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    This inn is named after Vice President Aaron Burr because some of Burr's dear friends lived in the original home that once stood on the site. The ghost of Burr has been seen here several tmes, especially on the second floor and its staircase. He has been known to tug ...


    Read more »

  • Ghosts of Manhattan
    Tara Leigh Parks
  • 0

    Wedgwood Inn Bed and Breakfast

    New Hope, Pennsylvania

    21.9 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    This 1870 inn on the site of a British fort boasts a basement tunnel, where munitions once were stored, and a secret staircase. And to make it more like something out of a spooky movie, the skeleton of a Hessian soldier was found in a basement chimney. The secret staircase, ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Wedgwood Inn Bed and Breakfast

    New Hope, Pennsylvania

    21.9 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    This 1878 inn, named after Josiah Wedgwood (of the china), is said to be haunted by the ghosts of Joseph Pickett and of a little girl named Sarah. A point of historic interest is that George Washington and his men camped on this land during the American Revolution, shortly before ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    1833 Umpleby House

    New Hope, Pennsylvania

    21.9 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Mill runners Colonel Buckley and Mr. Black are said to haunt this inn. Look for the light from the Colonel's lantern bobbing through the halls.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Kean University

    Union, New Jersey

    22 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Several places at Kean University, originally established in 1855 as the Newark Normal School, are said to be visited by spirits. East Campus and Rogers Hall are haunted by former students, the Eames building has a negative spirit, and the Wilkins Theater sports the ghost of a man named George ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Union County Courthouse

    Elizabeth, New Jersey

    22.2 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Investigated by TV's Ghost Hunters, the Union County Courthouse is said to be haunted by spirits from the Revolutionary War era. A woman's ghost has been seen in the rotunda, and Hannah Caldwell, the first woman to die in the American Revolution, is said to haunt a fifth floor courtroom ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Conant Park

    Hillside, New Jersey

    22.5 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Conant Park is said to be haunted by ghostly figures with no faces. According to legend, they drive a van and kidnap girls off the street, and when (if) the girls are released, they are far too frightened to explain what happened to them.


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Parsonage

    East Millstone, New York

    23.2 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The Parsonage, now closed, was a restaurant set inside an 1855 minister's home for the Reformed Dutch Church. It was said to be haunted by an apparition of a lady in 1800s clothing and a bonnet, who appeared between 10 p.m. and 2 a.m. in an upper window. Furthermore, apparitions ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Church of St Andrew

    East Millstone, New York

    23.2 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Investigated on an episode of TV's Ghost Hunters, the centuries-old church once was used as a makeshift Revolutionary War hospital. Witnesses have reported apparitions, unexplained sounds, pictures that fall off walls, footsteps, voices, a feeling of being watched, and an organ that plays by itself.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Historic Richmond Town

    East Millstone, New York

    23.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Historic Richmond Town, a living history village and museum complex, is rumored to have some haunted buildings. Some say the Guyon Lake Tysen House, built in 1740, is haunted by Elizabeth Lake Tysen. Some of her many children are suspected to linger here as well, playing with the house museum's ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Baron Hirsch Cemetery

    East Millstone, New York

    23.7 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The Jewish Baron Hirsch Cemetery was in the news for vandalism in 1960 when "Fuhrer" was painted in yellow on 87 headstones. It is said to have been haunted since the early 1800s. Nearby residents have had visits from the cemetery's spirits, sometimes seen as shadowy figures.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Old Seaview Hospital

    East Millstone, New York

    24.4 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Seaview Hospital, once a tuberculosis sanatorium, is now a national historic district on Staten Island. Built between 1905 and 1938, the site has over 30 historic buildings along Brielle Avenue. The former hospital building is reported to be haunted by the spirits of its deceased patients.


    Read more »
  • 0

    Black Bass Hotel

    New Hope, Pennsylvania

    24.9 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    It is said that at this 1745 historic inn, George Washington was once turned away by the loyal Tory innkeeper. Therefore, this hotel proudly states "George Washington did NOT sleep here!" A ghostly pool of blood appears on the floor in the tavern, a remnant from the time when early ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Widow McCrea House Victorian Bed and Breakfast

    Frenchtown, New Jersey

    25 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    This 1870's bed and breakfast inn is rumoured to have a ghostly feline roaming the halls. Guests have reported feeling a cat sitting on their bed, but upon investigation, there is nothing there. (Submitted by Callum Swift)


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Vanderbilt Tomb - Moravian Cemetery

    East Millstone, New York

    25.1 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Legends surrounding the Vanderbilt Tomb at Moravian Cemetery abound. One says the photos taken near it show an extra person or one of the people in the shot vanishes. Another says that inside the tomb, the Vanderbilts are not buried but are propped up like statues. The cemetery is believed ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    NJ Bar and Grill

    Mine Hill Township, New Jersey

    25.8 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    NJ Bar and Grill was the scene of a murder. Reports say long ago a man was killed by his mistress while he was playing pool here, and now his ghost lingers in the place where he passed. Witnesses say wine bottles float and then drop to the ground, and ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Robbins Reef Yacht Club

    Bayonne, New Jersey

    26 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    A ghostly legend about this place tells of a gentleman who hanged himself in an upstairs room. Witnesses describe an icy sensation when you enter that room in darkness and, at the bar, bottles seem to hop off of their shelves.


    Read more »
  • 0

    The Spy House - Seabrook-Wilson House

    Middletown, New Jersey

    26 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    Seabrook-Wilson House, also known as the Spy House, is said to be the first house on the Jersey shoreline. It was constructed by Thomas Whitlock in the 1600s and is rumored to be haunted. It operated as a tavern during the Revolutionary war, and reports say that British troops would ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Six Flags Great Adventure

    Jackson, New Jersey

    26.1 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    An unfortunately high number of guests have died here, from guest who fell off of Rolling Thunder, to another guest who died on the Lightnin' Loops attraction in 1987. However, most famously was the fire of the Haunted Castle which claimed teenagers. Mediums detect the presence of these people, but ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    White Hill Mansion

    Fieldsboro, New Jersey

    26.5 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The Revolutionary War created massive devastation in the colonies. Nowhere was this more evident than in New Jersey. Robert Field, a local business man and patriot, headed the Committee of Correspondence in an attempt to gain representation in British Parliament. In 1775 Robert drowned in the ...


    Read more »
  • 0

    Cunard Hall - Wagner College

    East Millstone, New York

    26.8 miles from East Millstone, NJ

    The circa-1852 Cunard Hall was built by Edward Cunard, son and heir of shipping magnate Samuel Cunard. It is now part of Wagner College. In 1890, a man leapt to his death from a second-story window, and witnesses have seen his face peering from the windows.


    Read more »

  • Big Book of New Jersey Ghost Stories
    Patricia A. Martinelli

    Ghosthunting New Jersey
    L'Aura Hladik


» Cemeteries near East Millstone, NJ

» Find museums in East Millstone, NJ